The fading grandeur of the Glen Canyon Dam Silt and erosion threaten to clog up the enduring structu

Discussion in 'Lake Powell Issues' started by Waterbaby, Oct 25, 2016.

  1. Waterbaby

    Waterbaby Administrator Staff Member

    The fading grandeur of the Glen Canyon Dam
    Silt and erosion threaten to clog up the enduring structure.

    Steve Tarlton Opinion Oct. 25, 2016 Web Exclusive

    Note: the opinions expressed in this column are those of the writer and do not necessarily reflect those of High Country News, its board or staff. If you'd like to share an opinion piece of your own, please write Betsy Marston at

    It was 1973, and as I looked over the newly created Lake Powell from the top of Glen Canyon Dam, I wondered what the river had been like before. The narrow gorge now spreading out the Colorado River seemed far less interesting than the labyrinth I tried to imagine beneath the placid water.

    Our tour guide noted, “Of course, the environmentalists think that saving that empty canyon is more important than providing basic services to millions of people.” One of my fellow Indian Health Service engineers chimed in: “Exactly where are the millions of people that will benefit from this project?”

    “Well,” our guide thought a minute, “Southern California, Phoenix and Tucson, I believe.”

    “What about the Navajo Reservation? Do they get any water or power?”

    “Well,” the guide answered, “I guess you could count the recreational benefits.” We all groaned.

    Our guide tried again: “If it weren’t for Glen Canyon, Lake Mead would fill up with silt in about 10 years.”

    In 1964, the American Society of Civil Engineers voted Glen Canyon Dam the outstanding engineering achievement of the year.
    Vicente Villamón, Flickr user
    This quickened our interest, so he elaborated, “It’s not really official, but nearly two-thirds of the capacity of Lake Mead has been lost due to inordinately high siltation rates. This upstream dam will intercept the silt and minimize the capacity loss at Lake Mead, prolonging its useful life.”

    Again the voice from a fellow engineer from the back, “How long before Lake Powell fills up with silt?” Our guide shook his head. “Do you have any idea how big this reservoir is? It won’t be a problem in our lifetime, I’ll guarantee.”

    Six months later, I gazed out across the desolate landscape of the Navajo Reservation where dry washes — rivers of sand — showed where water had flowed after the frequent — and violent — summer rains. Erosion was the predominant surface feature, and the flat ground was only relieved by a low range of buttes to the north.

    My Navajo translator and I had come to see a Navajo resident who wanted us to run water to his house from higher up the wash. Years ago, his father had worked for the federal Civilian Conservation Corps on a pipeline that brought the water down to the surrounding flats, where they had cultivated fields. On a sand dune covered with greasewood, he kicked aside a layer of sand to reveal a broken concrete pipe fully 18 inches in diameter. It was hard to believe that at any time in the last 40 years this arid parcel of desert had been irrigated, but the pipeline could be traced through the sand, mute evidence of some decayed dream to turn the desert green.

    The pipe led through the bed of a wash upstream until it reached a spot where the wash was blocked by a large volcanic dike. The volcanic walls were more resistant to erosion by the wind and water, so they protruded above the sandy soil, where the wash formed a V-shaped breach in the dike. The bottom half of the breach had been filled by hand-placed stone, grouted in place.

    This dam was a work of art, silent testimony to whatever craftsmen had labored to haul and place each stone in a giant mosaic that soared nearly 60 feet above the floor of the wash. None of us spoke, but we admired the structure in silence for a few moments.

    Looking down from the top of that dam, I remembered the view from a similar angle at Glen Canyon Dam. While the Colorado River had coursed as a silver thread through steep canyon walls, the dry wash here meandered through squat hills out to the sheep-dotted desert flats. Sand had replaced the reservoir. It shouldn’t have been surprising. How could anyone hope to overcome the forces of nature that decreed this vast land a desert?

    I pictured Lake Powell, as low now as it has ever been, completely filled with silt, a sandy surface of greasewood and sagebrush. Where Anglos had once come to play in the lake, sheep would once again wander and browse.

    No system of dams can capture and hold the Colorado River for long. How could we think that the dams we built a half-century ago were anything but temporary? The Bureau of Reclamation tour guide in 1973 seemed so confident about how long Glen Canyon Dam would endure, but I recall a scrawl of graffiti on a sandstone wall near a Lake Powell turnoff. It read: “NATURE BATS LAST.”

    Steve Tarlton is a contributor to Writers on the Range, the opinion service of
    High Country News. He is an environmental engineer who worked on the Navajo Indian Reservation from 1972 to 1974. He now lives in Golden, Colorado, and blogs at
    James Todd likes this.
  2. Waterbaby

    Waterbaby Administrator Staff Member

    High Country at it again......
  3. Leardriver

    Leardriver Well-Known Member

    The alleged conversations reek of selfishness. If it doesn't do me any good, who cares if it benefits society? Water for California? Preposterous. No power for the Navajo nation? Then who cares!
    Dwayne likes this.
  4. JBinNM

    JBinNM Active Member

    'He is an environmental engineer...' OK, we get it. They hate the dam and want it removed. Where is the Southwest supposed to get water if that happens? To hell with all that depend on it, should they just die off? No more crops, I guess that's OK too? No solutions, just whining.

    Neighbors up the street: can you kayak on Lake Powell? My reply: of course, but get something motorized and you'll see a lot more of it. I swear they gagged. I should have told them to put in at APM and go through the Maytag Straits. Just before the tour boat takes off...

    'The fading grandeur': if you meet someone that talks like this, run away very quickly.

    Now don't get me started on Bears Ears. :)

    I DO feel better.
  5. Endurance

    Endurance Well-Known Member

    I can't help but notice the last sentence of the story where the author cites with approval an anti-dam sentiment that is written in "a scrawl of graffiti on a sandstone wall near a Lake Powell turnoff." In that one sentence, he has unwittingly shown his own hypocrisy as well as that of the person who defaced natural sandstone to make a statement that they must think helps our environment.
    Last edited: Oct 27, 2016
  6. LovinPowell

    LovinPowell New Member

    At least it is a good picture of the dam and lake.
    James Todd and Waterbaby like this.
  7. wayne gustaveson

    wayne gustaveson Administrator Staff Member

    I do not know how to respond because I am not sure what the actual question is. I have been watching the lake fill, drain and refill since 1975. It seems to be working. Fishing and recreation are excelling. Electricity is being produced. Looks good to me for another 100-200 years. All things now constructed are only temporary in geological time.
    TR., Chris Cross, Sooner4ever and 3 others like this.
  8. Dungee Fishing

    Dungee Fishing Well-Known Member

    Enough with the common sense Wayne, they don't want to hear it!
    James Todd and Cutter99 like this.
  9. Bart

    Bart Well-Known Member

    Lake Powell and the other reservoirs are working as planned. They produce electrical energy directly and indirectly. One example of many: the Navajo power plant benefits from Lake Powell water, too.

    Second, water management can store water at higher elevations for less evaporation; also balances our wet and dry years. Reduces previous flooding of communities downstream. Look up the old pictures.

    Third, recreation and ...
    James Todd likes this.
  10. Cliff

    Cliff Well-Known Member

    I often wonder if we will ever reach a point when we say there is enough "wilderness" locked up behind ideological fences, "wilderness" that due to the rules gets used by maybe % of the US population? Or will it always be just a rally against any kind of development?

    There are people who benefit from development. Lots of people.
    Until the human population stops growing, land is going to have to be used.
    Everything we ever look at in the environment is always viewed with a blink of the eye geologically speaking.

    Extrapolation is a very risky business of forecasting.
    Chris Cross and Bart like this.
  11. tt600

    tt600 Active Member

    I was at the inlet to Lake Mead the other day. There is a lot of silt there. 20 feet deep in places. Now being cut by the lower river. But seeing that Lake Mead is 140 feet below full pool I am sure the useful life is many hundreds of years.
    Bill Sampson likes this.
  12. shanewave

    shanewave Active Member

    High in High Country is more like it.