I only want to share this for perspective for anyone reading this thread who's really trying to figure out what's best for them. This is only FYI information but I'll share some personal info that might help you out.
Someone earlier in this thread mentioned that he's getting two amazing trips a year for $10,000. Rental rates are higher than that and he's getting a concierge experience there with Lake Time. He doesn’t have to do much for himself, it’s handled and there is real value in that. I can't speak for others but I'll share my ownership experience for comparison and contrast. Outside of not counting my capitalized costs, our initial investment, my houseboat partner and I spend about 10k each a year to moor, insure and maintain our houseboat. For that we get up to 26 weeks each every year to use our houseboat.
Our boat is a 1998, 16x60 4 bedroom 1 and 1/2 bath aluminum monohull in good condition. So out of that 20 K a year we squirrel away about $3,000 a year for a refit/rainy day fund. Unexpected expenses can happen any time with an old boat so you've got to be ready to stroke checks outside of the minimums if necessary, potentially some hefty ones. This is no small detail, you have to carry this risk if you become an owner. So far we have not had to do much of that but I do all the maintenance and repair work myself. (I don't charge for my time, I'm kind of a control freak about the work that gets done on it, that works great for both of us) We are week on/week off on our schedule all year.
So, for us our family gets up there about 20 weekends(some long) a year including 2 to 4 week long trips a year total between winter and summer. Sometimes my wife and I just decide last minute to run up and relax as a getaway for the weekend which you can only do if you have a boat in a slip waiting for you. So ownership with just one partner works for us and our cost is about $500 a week IF we can use it twenty times a year. But maybe even better than the low cost per week is having the freedom and flexibility to get there at our convenience. If there is a conflict in my schedule, a relatives weeding or a big event in one of my kids lives etc. I’m not bound and locked down to any certain week. I can always go on my next turn or even the next week if my parter is not planning on being there. Our collective belief as partners is that the houseboat is expensive to keep and should be used as much as possible by us and if he’s not using it I can and vice versa without remuneration, it’s in our operating agreement.
For our partnership it helps that we both live close, I live near by in Flagstaff and my partner who is my cousin, he's in St George. Our initial downstroke was real and again is not considered in this equation but I think that we will get most of that if not all of it back when we sell someday. Our boat sold new for about $160,000 and we paid that for it 3 years ago and I think I could get that for it now or three years from now as long as it's in good condition. New boats like ours are almost $500,000 and that seems to help support the values of good used ones. But, buying a houseboat is the cheapest thing you'll ever do with it, keeping it going and paying moorage over the years is the expensive part.
Usually if it flies or floats it's cheaper to rent but it's not necessarily true of houseboats at Powell. Even if I only got four week long trips in a year on our boat I'd only be in the $2,500 a week range based on 10 k a year as my half of fixed expenses. Like I say no right or wrong way to enjoy our lake, this is just an FYI for curious people trying to understand their options. Getting into sole ownership or a partnership probably fits best for avid frequent users.
If you could get four good boaters together and you could each throw down 40k to buy a boat you could get up to 13 weeks on the lake for 5k a year but you have to be committed. Point is that house boat ownership doesn’t have to be only for the very wealthy, with creativity and work you can make it affordable for more moderately successful Joes. it's a super value for families who want to have fun and adventure together. Traveling is so expensive these days, air fare, lodging, meals out, entertainment cost more than ever. At Powell, on your houseboat that’s all built in, you just pay for fuel.