@Marina Bum.I like the way you think. Functionality and performance over appearance, like a rat rod.If you don't care so much how pretty they are, Hydrochloric Acid aka Muriatic Acid in a pump sprayer. (the sprayer is usually good one time) You can wear rubber gloves and a respirator with purple cartridges if you want, maybe a Tyvek suit too. It will dull the aluminum overall but it will get it clean, all organics dissolved! IDC about shine, I want less drag and more speed, crud really slows down a pontoon. The pontoons wont be shiny in time anyway, get it over with and get them clean. IMO

Are those aluminum pontoons on a 1980 Boatel? I’m curious what it cost to do the steel-to-aluminum conversion?
We blasted and ‘skinned’ our 1980 Kayot steel pontoons in 2015. Coated with fresh 3M Coal Tar Epoxy. She sits on a trailer year round…in the water maybe 40-50 days a year.
As you surely know, a steel boat always rusts from the inside, even if it’s sitting high and dry on land. We’ve had to do some patches the last couple of years. So far we’ve been keeping up with it for relatively little cost.
But at some point aluminum conversion may be the longer term solution. And yes, we KNOW it’ll cost FAR MORE than the boat’s total worth. But to us, Yachtzee has been and always will be our low-cost, fun-as-hell mobile campsite so common sense goes out the window.
Curious to hear your take…
A Yachtzee passing last May!!!! Tobasco? Cleaning Vinegar? I can't tell the difference between the two.Hot Sauce will amaze you!
The early Yachtzee on Lake Mead.View attachment 31877A Yachtzee passing last May!!!!![]()

Who fabricated your aluminum toons? I am currently exploring options to convert my old rusted-out steel toons to aluminum. Any insight or advice is greatly appreciated.@Marina Bum.I like the way you think. Functionality and performance over appearance, like a rat rod.
She's a 1980 Boatel and shiny pontoons don't fit with the rat rod look.View attachment 31864