Coal Powerplant to pull out of Page


Staff member

Navajo Generating Station gets a short-term reprieve
Posted: Wednesday, Feb 15th, 2017
BY: David Rupkalvis

Navajo Generating Station may have received a three-year reprieve Monday.

The owners of NGS voted to keep the power plant open and running until the end of 2019, if they can reach an agreement with the Navajo Nation.

Currently, NGS has a lease with the Navajo Nation that expires at the end of 2019. To keep the plant operating until then, the Navajo tribe would have to agree to extend the lease so NGS would have time to tear down the plant. Without an agreement, the plant could still close as early as this summer.

During the meeting Monday, the owners also agreed to let the Navajo and Hopi tribes take over the plant at the end of 2019, if the tribes choose to do so. The non-governmental owners vow to end a business relationship with NGS at that time. The federal Bureau of Reclamation, which owns 24.3 percent of NGS, did not vote to close the plant and could be interested in remaining involved after 2019.

The four utility owners of NGS include Salt River Project, Arizona Public Service Co., NV Energy and Tucson Electric Power.

“The utility owners do not make this decision lightly,” said Mike Hummel, deputy general manager of SRP, the plant’s operator. “NGS and its employees are one reason why this region, the state of Arizona and the Phoenix metropolitan area have been able to grow and thrive. However, SRP has an obligation to provide low-cost service to our more than 1 million customers and the higher cost of operating NGS would be borne by our customers.”

In recent years, the cost of operating NGS, a coal-powered plant, has grown while the cost of operating natural gas powered plants has plummeted. The utility owners made it clear Monday, the cost of doing business is the sole reason they are looking to leave NGS when the current lease with the Navajo Nation expires.

Hummel explained recent studies have shown the cost of producing electricity at NGS is greater than the open market, and as long as natural gas prices remain low, that gap is expected to continue.

For the complete article see the 02-15-2017 issue.

Click here to purchase an electronic version of the 02-15-2017 paper.


Staff member
From what I read, natural gas would have to be piped in from flagstaff, solar and wind not reliable, cheaper to build a new plant.
The Navajo Reservation has a lot of locked up wealth in their minerals, but a couple of years ago they had all their uranium locked up, seemingly forever, they have oil and natural gas reserves as well as really good coal. They spent a lot of money to upgrade their coal operation, and it provided very nice jobs on the reservation, only to have it all closed down when the power plant in Laughlin was dismantled... When you see the signs for their housing being section 8 because these people are so poor and know they could be so prosperous it's sad.